Glimmers of hope in latest Eurozone money numbers
Simon Ward
3 Comments
Eurozone monetary trends are improving at the margin, suggesting that the ECB’s rate cuts and liquidity injections have been at least partially effective and consistent with a stabilisation of EMU-wide output by the late summer. A recovery, moreover, has occurred in the periphery as well as the core in the last two months, a development that – if sustained – could herald an end to recessions in the former group by late 2012.
The key monetary forecasting indicator employed here is the six-month change in real narrow money M1, which outperforms the broader M3 measure. This turned heavily negative in early 2011, warning of the current recession. It recovered to -0.1% (not annualised) in March, consistent with industrial output stabilising from around September, allowing for the usual six-month lead – see first chart.
M1 comprises currency in circulation and overnight deposits. The ECB publishes a country breakdown of deposits but not currency. In the six months to March, real M1 deposits rose by 2.8% (not annualised) in the “core” (i.e. Germany, France, Benelux, Austria) but fell by 3.7% in the “periphery” (Italy, Spain, Greece, Portugal, Ireland). The peripheral decline, however, eased from 5.6% in February – second chart.
The six-month changes continue to be dominated by monetary weakness in late 2011 / January 2012. EMU-wide real M1 deposits rose by a solid 1.0% in February and March combined, with similar increases in the core and periphery – third chart.
It is still early days but a further recovery in peripheral real M1 would suggest an end to recessions by late 2012. The risk, however, is that the lagged impact of the ECB’s rate cuts and liquidity injections will be offset by the recent renewed rise in financial tensions, reflected in wider peripheral / core spreads. Further ECB rate cuts are warranted to reduce this risk.
View Printer Friendly Version
Email Article to Friend
Reader Comments (3)
Great post Simon. My question is whether Eurozone stabilisation could offset a potential US slowdown in the quarters ahead at the global level? If not I presume the S&P500 is set to take a bath in the coming months. Thanks!
Mr. Ward, I´m afraid this report is quite useless as a forecaster. I tell you why: M1 can go up for a lot of reasons, not only because there are more transactions in a country (which would point to more growth) but also because interest rates banks are paying are very low (so people decides to keep their money at home or on a current account), or because banks are perceived to be more risky ( this seems to be the case of some european countries now) and also because there is fear that bank´s accounts (specially term, interest bearing accounts) will be redenominated in national currencies, so the monetary increases and M1 increases too. So, I.m afraid your analysis is useless at least in the eurozone case.
Walter, The recent increase in M1 is unlikely to be attributable to the factors you suggest IMO. M1 was certainly not useless as a forecaster last year - it signalled an oncoming recession even as the ECB and consensus remained optimistic, as described here at the time (e.g. http://www.moneymovesmarkets.com/journal/2011/5/16/eurozone-gdp-celebration-may-prove-short-lived.html).