Eurozone money trends also signalling improving outlook

Posted on Monday, October 27, 2014 at 03:48PM by Registered CommenterSimon Ward | CommentsPost a Comment

Eurozone money measures grew solidly again in September, suggesting improving economic prospects and initial success for the ECB’s recent easing measures.

Narrow money M1 has risen by 2.5%, or 10.3% annualised, since June, when the ECB cut its main refinancing and deposit rates by 10 basis points (bp), the latter to a negative level. Broad money M3 has increased by 1.3%, or 5.4% annualised, over the same period. The ECB lowered rates by a further 10 bp in September.

The monetary pick-up casts strong doubt on the IMF’s recent estimate of a 40% chance of a recession by mid-2015. The six-month change in real (i.e inflation-adjusted) M1 turned negative ahead of the 2008-09 and 2011-12 recessions; it is currently the strongest since late 2012, ahead of the 2013 economic recovery – see first chart.

Six-month real M3 growth, meanwhile, is the highest since 2009. (Real M3, however, is less reliable than M1 as a leading indicator, failing, for example, to signal the 2008-09 recession in advance.)

Stronger real money trends reflect a rise in nominal expansion rather than lower inflation. The six-month change in consumer prices, seasonally adjusted, has recovered since the spring, though remains weak – second chart.

Monetary acceleration undermines the popular narrative that the ECB is “behind the curve” and must embrace full QE including sovereign bond purchases to head off deflation. The ECB’s rate cuts, indeed, appear to have been more effective in stimulating monetary growth than the Bank of Japan’s ultra-aggressive QE programme. As previously discussed, Japanese QE has, until recently, involved commercial banks swapping bonds for central bank reserves, with no impact on the money holdings of households and non-financial firms. Japanese M3 rose by 3.2% annualised in the three months to September versus 5.4% growth in the Eurozone.

The ECB publishes a country breakdown of overnight deposits, comprising about 80% of Eurozone M1. Six-month real deposit growth remains higher in the periphery than the core, suggesting superior economic and equity market prospects – third chart. Trends are strongest in Portugal and Spain but Italy is outperforming Germany and France – fourth chart.


Japanese money trends signalling improving outlook

Posted on Friday, October 24, 2014 at 11:22AM by Registered CommenterSimon Ward | CommentsPost a Comment

Posts last year (e.g. here) suggested that Japanese economic and equity market performance would disappoint in 2014. This pessimism was based on the failure of QE to boost monetary growth significantly and the expected inflation impact of the April sales tax rise. The real money supply, in other words, was on course to contract, making continued economic expansion unlikely.

The negative view was reinforced by a monetary slowdown during the first half of 2014. Six-month growth of narrow money M1 fell to a 51-month low in July, with the broader aggregates also showing significant weakness – see first chart.

The money measures, however, have bounced back solidly in August and September. The negative impact of the sales tax hike, meanwhile, is waning. The six-month rise in consumer prices, seasonally adjusted but not annualised, should drop from 2.4% in August – the latest available number – to about 1.0% in October.

The second chart includes October estimates of six-month real money growth assuming that nominal growth is unchanged from September and inflation falls back as expected. The suggestion is that real money trends now support a resumption of economic expansion.

Money growth remains subdued but QE could be gaining greater traction. As previously discussed, the initial monetary impact was small because the Bank of Japan (BoJ) bought securities mainly from banks. The rate of decline of banks' bond holdings, however, has slowed sharply since early 2014. This may reflect increased BoJ buying from government pension funds, who are under strong pressure to reduce their domestic bond weighting.

Japanese industrial output has slumped since early 2014 but should – as in other countries – post a strong rebound in September. Trade figures this week support this expectation: export volume rose by 1.8% from August and is up 3.6% since June – third chart. The October “flash” manufacturing purchasing managers’ survey, meanwhile, was encouraging, with the forward-looking new orders component at its highest since February.


Chinese September data more evidence of global resilience

Posted on Tuesday, October 21, 2014 at 10:18AM by Registered CommenterSimon Ward | CommentsPost a Comment

Stronger-than-expected Chinese industrial output in September confirms that global production rebounded solidly last month, casting doubt on recent growth pessimism based partly on weak August data.

Chinese output rose by a seasonally-adjusted* 1.7% on the month after a 0.5% loss in August. Six-month growth was 4.2%, or 8.5% annualised – the second highest reading over the last eight months (after July).

Monetary trends suggest continued moderate economic expansion. Real M2 seems to outperform M1 as a leading indicator in China; its six-month growth is in line with the average over the last five years – see first chart. Real bank loan expansion also remains stable at a respectable level, although the wider “total social financing” credit measure has been slowing gradually, in line with official objectives – second chart.

Three countries in the G7 plus emerging E7 group have now reported industrial output for September: China, the US and Russia – see also Friday’s post. On conservative assumptions about developments elsewhere**, six-month industrial output growth for the group is estimated to have returned to its level in June. The leading indicators tracked here suggest that growth will continue to firm into early 2015 – third chart.

*Based on World Bank seasonal adjustments.
**Japanese output is assumed to rise by 3.0% in September versus a 6.0% increase suggested by a METI survey of manufacturers. Eurozone output is assumed to recover by 1.0% after a 1.8% August decline as car production rebounds from holiday-affected weakness – see Friday’s post. Output is assumed unchanged in all other countries.



September data suggesting global industrial resilience

Posted on Friday, October 17, 2014 at 02:48PM by Registered CommenterSimon Ward | CommentsPost a Comment

A surprise August drop in global industrial output contributed to current market growth worries but incoming September data suggest a strong rebound.

Two countries in the G7 plus emerging E7 aggregate monitored here have so far reported for September: the US and Russia. Output rose by a stronger-than-expected 1.0% on the month in both cases, more than reversing August falls of 0.2% and 0.3% respectively*.

Outside this group, Polish industrial output rebounded 1.4% last month, also beating market forecasts.

Germany last week reported a 4.0% August output drop but this followed a 1.6% gain in July. The numbers have been heavily distorted by holiday timing effects in the auto sector – car production surged 25% in July before slumping 28% in August. Car output rebounded 19% in September, suggesting that industrial production will reverse most of its August drop – see chart.

Japanese industrial output fell by 1.9% in August but manufacturers’ polled at the time the report was compiled expected production to surge by 6.0% in September. Their forecasts have been consistently too optimistic in recent months but the August loss, at a minimum, should be regained.

China has the largest weight in the G7 plus E7 aggregate and reports September production on Tuesday 21 October. Recent output growth has been lower than suggested by official and Markit manufacturing purchasing managers' surveys, while a rise in September exports is hopeful.

*All numbers seasonally adjusted. Own adjustment of Russian / Polish industrial output and German car output using X12.

Global money trends flashing amber not red

Posted on Thursday, October 16, 2014 at 11:41AM by Registered CommenterSimon Ward | CommentsPost a Comment

Global six-month real narrow money growth – the key forecasting indicator monitored here – appears to have partially reversed a sharp August fall in September, based on data covering 60% of the aggregate. The recent behaviour of the indicator suggests that industrial output growth will rebound near-term before declining again from early 2015.

Real narrow money growth fell during the second half of 2013, correctly signalling an economic slowdown during the first half of 2014 – see chart. It revived in early 2014, however, resulting in a forecast here of a recovery in economic momentum from the summer, based on an average half-year lead from money to activity. Economic weakness, instead, has extended, with six-month industrial output growth falling to a 21-month low in August. This extension is consistent with normal variation in the money / activity lead time.

Real narrow money growth remained solid through July but dropped sharply in August. The preliminary data suggest that it remained well below the first-half average in September.

To summarise, real money trends do not support market fears that the global economy is sliding into another recession. Such a scenario would require that 1) the rise in real money growth in early 2014 was a false signal and will not be reflected in a near-term recovery in output growth and 2) the economy will enter a recession without a prior real money contraction – historically a rare occurrence.

As stated in a post last week, the expectation of a recovery in output growth will be maintained unless real money expansion or the longer leading indicator tracked here weaken further. The leading indicator was little changed in August while an energy-driven fall in inflation will support real money growth near term.